Free lesson

The Magic Between Panels: How Readers Fill in the Story

The Magic Between Panels: How Readers Fill in the Story — Make Your Own Comics — Even If You Can't Draw. The gap where the action happens; Six kinds of transition; The pause as a panel; Three versions of the same strip; How to edit the gaps. Practical assignment: Rework your first strip.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • The gap where the action happens
  • Six kinds of transition
  • The pause as a panel
  • Three versions of the same strip
  • How to edit the gaps

The gap where the action happens

Between two panels there is usually an empty space called the gutter. Nothing is printed there, yet the reader connects separate pictures into one event. Scott McCloud calls this meaningful completion of missing information closure.

Imagine two panels. In the first, a person holds a glass of water over a sleeping friend. In the second, the friend is sitting up, soaked and angry. The falling water and the awakening were never shown, but cause and effect make them easy to reconstruct.

The author decides which moments actually need drawing. When an omitted action follows clearly from the neighboring panels, it can often remain in the gutter. That reduces the drawing required and gives the reader an active role. The omission still needs the right evidence: wet clothes establish the result, while the glass establishes a likely cause.

Fictional example. In a long version, a man sees a “Wet paint” sign, touches the bench, studies his green hand, and sighs—4 panels. In a 2-panel version, he reads the sign suspiciously and then walks away; a handprint remains behind him. The touch can be omitted because the sign and print form a clear connection. Remove the sign as well, and the green print may seem arbitrary.

Six kinds of transition

McCloud’s classification helps describe the size and nature of the jump between two panels.

  • Moment-to-moment: a very small change in time—eyes open → blink. It slows an event and captures a small change.
  • Action-to-action: the same subject advances to another action—throw → ball in flight.
  • Subject-to-subject: the scene remains, but the focus changes—person looks → clock reveals they are late.
  • Scene-to-scene: a substantial jump in time or place—morning at home → evening at the station.
  • Aspect-to-aspect: different details of a place, idea, or mood—rain on glass → cold cup → empty chair.
  • Non sequitur: neighboring panels have no apparent logical connection. It can serve absurdity or experimentation, but gives the reader no certain bridge to build.

The labels are analytical tools, not rigid rules. The practical question is simpler: what must the reader infer between these panels? A jump that is too small can spend space on predictable movement; one that is too large can hide a cause, a new participant, or a change of location. For example, “approaches door → grips handle → opens door → enters” can become “stands outside → is inside” when the method of entry does not matter. If the door is locked and the character must break it, that method is now part of the story.

The pause as a panel

A panel without dialogue can mark a pause, reaction, or expectation. A new panel creates a separate reading beat: characters remain silent, exchange a look, or appear in an almost repeated view. In a humorous strip, such a beat can sit before the outcome so the reader has time to notice the discomfort or anticipate the consequence.

A pause earns space when it changes how the scene is read: it shows hesitation, offence, realization, or another important reaction. A Reddit discussion among comics creators draws a useful boundary: an ordinary delay in conversation can be skipped, while a meaningful reaction may deserve its own panel. That is practical community advice, not a universal law.

Fictional example: panel 1—Nina asks, “Did you water the cactus?”; panel 2—Marco silently studies the empty pot; panel 3—a “SPLASH” comes from the overflowing sink behind him. Add “Oh, I think I forgot” to panel 2 and the pause explains what the picture already conveys, weakening the beat. A common mistake is adding a silent panel after every line. Important pauses then become indistinguishable from the strip’s ordinary pace.

Three versions of the same strip

The entire example below is fictional; its results are not research. Eva revisits her morning-run strip. In the original, panel 3 says, “Okay. Five minutes. For you,” and panel 4 says, “Running is a state of mind.” The words state something the images could already communicate.

In version B, she removes panel 2: Eva jumps from bed at 7:00, and the next panel immediately shows her pinned under Biscuit the cat at 9:40. This is a large scene-to-scene jump; the reader supplies the failed run. Version C keeps 4 panels, but panel 3 becomes a silent close-up of Eva and Biscuit staring at each other. Panel 4 contains only 9:40 and the untouched running shoes.

To test them, an author could show all three versions to three people in varied orders without identifying the new one. Record specific evidence: where each person pauses, what they infer between panels, where they expect the outcome, and where they ask for clarification. A smile can be a useful observation, but it does not prove that one version is objectively best. The aim also matters: B is quicker; C holds the reaction longer. The test looks for clarity and the intended rhythm, not one “correct” answer.

How to edit the gaps

Start with the transitions rather than the drawing quality. Under every pair of panels, write brief answers to two questions: “What happened in the gap?” and “How does the reader know?” If cause and result make the answer obvious, try removing the intermediate panel. If several incompatible explanations remain possible, restore one clue: an object, a changed pose, a time caption, or an establishing panel.

Next, make two controlled versions. In the cut version, remove one predictable step. In the pause version, replace one explanatory line with a silent reaction. Avoid changing the plot, ending, and character designs at the same time, or you will not know what changed the rhythm.

Common mistakes include drawing every mechanical movement, making a jump with no visual cause, adding a pause that changes nothing, explaining a visible reaction in dialogue, and treating every misunderstanding as “reader participation.” A useful omission supplies enough anchors for the intended inference. If a fresh reader cannot say what happened, the problem may be missing evidence rather than poor attention.

Practical assignment

Rework your first strip

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. Your First Comic in 20 Minutes — No Drawing Skills Needed
  2. The Magic Between Panels: How Readers Fill in the Story
  3. Ideas and Characters: What to Make Comics About
  4. The Script: Full Script, Plot-First and How to Write for Yourself
  5. Thumbnails: Plan a Page in Five Minutes Before You Draw
  6. Shot, Angle and Pose: How to “Film” a Scene
  7. Tools: Paper, Phone and Free Software
  8. Lettering: Words That Get Read in the Right Order
  9. Finish It: Final Art, a Time Budget and “Good Enough”
  10. Publishing: WEBTOON, Tapas, Instagram and Your First Readers