Free lesson

What an Argument Is Made Of

What an Argument Is Made Of — Critical Thinking: Check Claims, Spot Traps and Change Your Mind Well. Argument, opinion or noise; The four parts of a map; Where reasoning breaks; A strong reason and a weak one; Map without distortion. Practical assignment: Map one argument.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • Argument, opinion or noise
  • The four parts of a map
  • Where reasoning breaks
  • A strong reason and a weak one
  • Map without distortion

Argument, opinion or noise

During the pause before a decision, first identify what is in front of you. An argument is a conclusion that someone invites you to accept plus at least one reason offered in support. “We should change suppliers because the new supplier’s price is 12% lower” is an argument.

“This supplier is the best” is only an opinion until a reason is supplied. “Its price is 12% lower” is a separate claim that does not yet say what to do. “I like them” reports the speaker’s feeling, but does not by itself support a business decision.

A useful response to an opinion is “why?”, to an isolated fact “what follows from that?”, and to a feeling “what produced it?” Even a true fact is not yet an argument until it is connected to a particular conclusion.

The four parts of a map

A practical argument map has four parts:

  1. Conclusion — what you are being asked to believe or do.
  2. Reasons — claims offered to support the conclusion. In logic they are also called premises.
  3. Hidden assumptions — unstated claims needed to move from a reason to the conclusion.
  4. Evidence — what gives you grounds to accept a reason: a record, document, measurement or checkable example.

In “They are cheaper, so we should switch,” the conclusion is to switch and the reason is the lower price. The bridge may be an assumption that quality, timing and reliability are no worse, or that the price difference outweighs any disadvantages. To find that bridge, ask: “What else would have to be true for this conclusion to follow?” Do not add everything imaginable; look for the weakest sufficient assumption needed for this particular move.

Where reasoning breaks

A reason can be true while the move to the conclusion is weak. In an explicitly fictional example, a competitor launched an app and its sales rose the following month. That does not yet establish that the app caused the increase or that an app would help another company. Prices, advertising or seasonal demand might have changed at the same time.

Test two things separately: is the reason acceptable? and does it support the conclusion strongly enough? “Customers love the service” without a source is another unsupported claim. Reports from three named customers are some evidence, but those customers may not represent the whole customer base.

Common mistakes include arguing only about the visible fact while leaving the bridge untested, treating sequence as causation, demanding impeccable support from the other side but not your own, and assuming that one weakness proves the opposite conclusion.

A strong reason and a weak one

After mapping the argument, test each branch with four questions. Is the reason true, and how could you check? Is the hidden assumption credible? Does the evidence address this claim rather than a nearby topic? What happens to the conclusion if this reason is removed?

Fictional example. A salesperson says: “Three local builders switched to our panels and are happy. Our panels are 12% cheaper. You should switch too.” The salesperson’s word is currently the only support for the first reason; “happy” is undefined, and the builders may have different needs. A price sheet supports the quoted price, but not quality or delivery. A sensible next move is to request comparable specifications, customer contacts with permission, and a limited trial. The map does not decide automatically; it shows which information is missing.

Map without distortion

First rewrite the conclusion as one neutral sentence. Then state each reason as accurately and strongly as its author did. Do not turn “may help” into “will certainly work.” Under every reason, record the evidence and the minimum assumption connecting it to the conclusion. If the conclusion was not stated, label it as your interpretation.

Next identify the weakest link: a doubtful reason, an untested assumption, mismatched evidence or an inference that reaches too far. Make the follow-up request specific. Instead of “give me more proof,” ask, for example, “show the defect rate for the same period and delivery volume.” Apply the same process to an argument you agree with. Otherwise mapping can become a tool for selective criticism rather than a check on reasoning.

Practical assignment

Map one argument

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. The Fast Answer and the Right Answer
  2. What an Argument Is Made Of
  3. Five Reasoning Traps
  4. Five Distraction Tricks
  5. Always Right: Confirmation and My-Side Bias
  6. The Blind Spot: Why Biases Are Easy to See in Others
  7. The Base Rate: Out of How Many?
  8. Vivid Is Not the Same as Common
  9. Say How Sure You Are
  10. Keep Score: Calibration
  11. Consider the Opposite
  12. Changing Your Mind Without Losing Face
  13. Arguing to Find the Truth
  14. Your Everyday Toolkit