Free lesson

Good Enough Beats Perfect

Good Enough Beats Perfect — Make Decisions With Confidence: Stop Going in Circles. Two ways to choose; Is too much choice the problem?; The good-enough rule; Default rules: decide once; When to stop—and when to continue. Practical assignment: Close one small decision.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • Two ways to choose
  • Is too much choice the problem?
  • The good-enough rule
  • Default rules: decide once
  • When to stop—and when to continue

Two ways to choose

Consider an ordinary purchase: headphones, a backpack, or a desk lamp. One approach is to seek the best option that might exist. This is called maximizing. Another is to set acceptable conditions in advance and stop at the first option that meets them. This is satisficing: choosing an option that satisfies your requirements and is sufficient for the job.

These are approaches, not two fixed kinds of person. Someone may compare carefully when choosing a home and use a simple cutoff for a household item. A detailed Reddit discussion about choosing a game illustrates the practical problem with maximizing: time goes into reviews and comparisons instead of playing. Commenters also made a useful qualification—the importance of the decision should determine the depth of the search.

A study of graduating students seeking jobs found a mixed result. Participants with strong maximizing tendencies obtained starting salaries about 20% higher, yet reported less satisfaction with their jobs and more negative emotion during the search. That is the finding of one study, not a promise about every decision. Maximizing can sometimes improve a measured outcome, but it consumes time and can keep attention on rejected alternatives.

Is too much choice the problem?

The famous jam experiment is often retold as proof that many options always paralyze people. A later meta-analysis covering 63 conditions from 50 published and unpublished experiments, with 5,036 participants, found an average effect close to zero and substantial variation between studies. The simple rule “fewer options are always better” is therefore unsupported.

Choice overload is more likely when options are complex or hard to compare, the task is difficult, preferences are uncertain, or the goal is to find the single best option. The practical response is to decide what you need before opening the catalogue or search results.

A common mistake is to open ten tabs and invent the criteria while browsing. Each product then contributes another desired feature: the price of one, the design of another, and a function from a third. The wish list expands, and the search becomes harder to finish.

The good-enough rule

For a small, reversible decision, use four steps:

  1. Write 2–3 must-haves—without them, an option fails.
  2. Give each must-have a clear threshold: a number or a yes/no test.
  3. Set a search limit that matches the consequences of the decision.
  4. Take the first option that clears every threshold, then stop searching.

Fictional example. Alma is choosing a gym with a pool. Her must-haves are: no more than 15 minutes from home, a pool, and a monthly price no higher than $50. She allows 10 minutes for the search. The first two gyms fail. The third is 12 minutes away, has a pool, and costs $42. It passes all three conditions, so Alma chooses it.

Good enough does not mean low standards. The thresholds may be demanding; the method simply creates a visible stopping point. A 10-minute rule is inappropriate for an irreversible, expensive, or safety-critical decision. Such a decision needs broader criteria, verified information, and a separate examination of risk.

Default rules: decide once

Some small decisions are not stuck; they simply return: what to cook on a weekday, which paper to order, or what to give a colleague. A default rule is an answer chosen in advance for a category of recurring situations. Examples include, “Weekday dinners come from my list of five meals,” and, “For a needed household item under $30, I take the first option that meets my two requirements.”

A default needs a boundary. It should not automatically carry over from cheap, reversible purchases to medical, financial, or safety-related choices. Review it if the price, need, or consequence of an error changes.

There is no need to justify defaults with the claim that everyone has a fixed daily supply of willpower. Evidence about “decision fatigue” is mixed, and the famous account of judges deciding cases differently before a break has alternative explanations, including case order and duration. The more dependable practical benefit is simpler: a default reduces repeated searching and saves time.

When to stop—and when to continue

Stopping is justified when the criteria were written before the search, an option clears every must-have, the decision can be cancelled or redone, and further searching is unlikely to change an important consequence. If you keep looking “just in case,” name the information that could genuinely change the choice. If you cannot name it, the search is no longer serving the decision.

Continue checking when no option passes, the information source is unreliable, an error could cause substantial harm, or the choice is hard to reverse. Do not lower an important threshold merely because the timer expired. Change the search plan or accept that no suitable option is currently available.

After choosing, close the tabs and set a short no-comparison period. This does not forbid reconsideration: a material new fact can justify reopening the decision. The purpose is to avoid restarting it for every minor difference.

Practical assignment

Close one small decision

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. Why Deciding Feels So Hard — and Where to Start
  2. Good Enough Beats Perfect
  3. What Is the Real Question?
  4. More Options: Think “And,” Not “Or”
  5. Criteria and Weights: Your Decision Matrix
  6. How Much Information Is Enough?
  7. Traps: The Status Quo, Sunk Costs and Fear of Loss
  8. Emotions and Gut Feeling: Allies With Limits
  9. The Outside View and Other People's Advice
  10. The Premortem and Your Plan B
  11. Decide — and Get On With Your Life
  12. Your Decision Protocol and Decision Journal