Free lesson

Why Most People Price Wrong

Why Most People Price Wrong — 💰 Pricing Strategy for Digital Products. Price is the lever nobody pulls; Three ways people pick a price; From guessing to Willingness to Pay; Why smart founders underprice; Let price grow with your customer; Practice: audit your current price. Practical assignment: Complete a one-page pricing audit.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • Price is the lever nobody pulls
  • Three ways people pick a price
  • From guessing to Willingness to Pay
  • Why smart founders underprice
  • Let price grow with your customer
  • Practice: audit your current price

Price is the lever nobody pulls

“Let's charge $12: similar tools cost around ten, and ours is a little better.” That is how the price is chosen for Taskbook, a fictional project-management app for small agencies used in this course. Its free plan has three projects and basic boards. Pro includes unlimited projects, automations and a client portal for $12 per user per month.

The decision sounds understandable, but tells us little about the buyer. What work does Taskbook help them complete? What do they use today? Would they pay by employee, project or some other unit? Until those questions are investigated, $12 is a hypothesis to test.

Consider a separate fictional calculation. A company sells 100 units at $100 each. Its total costs at that volume are $8,000. Revenue is $10,000 and profit in this simplified model is $2,000. If the price rises to $101 while sales volume and total costs stay unchanged, revenue becomes $10,100 and profit becomes $2,100. Price increased by 1%; profit increased by 5%.

This calculation does not establish that buyers will accept the increase. If some leave, sales volume and costs change. The effect must therefore be calculated for the actual conditions. The historical 2003 McKinsey discussion likewise considers price effects under specified assumptions; it does not guarantee an identical outcome for every business.

Return to Taskbook with two questions: what value does the customer receive, and what are they comparing $12 with? The next steps examine pricing approaches that can leave those questions unanswered.

Three ways people pick a price

Three ways people pick a price

Ask founders how they chose their price and you'll hear some version of these:

| Method | What it sounds like | What it misses | | --- | --- | --- | | Cost-plus | "Our costs are $30, we add 50%" | What the customer gains | | Competitor-based | "We're 20% cheaper than X" | Your unique value — and X may be wrong | | "Feels right" | "$99 just sounded good" | Any data at all |

Cost-plus is the most common, because it feels responsible. But your costs have nothing to do with the value you create. If your tool solves a $10,000 problem and costs you $100 to deliver, charging $150 leaves almost all the value on the table. Cost-plus also rewards the wrong things: when costs go up, the price goes up, so there's no incentive to be efficient — you're paid more for spending more, not for creating more value.

Competitor-based pricing sounds smart but assumes the competitor figured pricing out. Often they guessed too. It also treats your product as identical to theirs, which pushes everyone to compete on features and discounts — and someone always wants to be the cheapest, which is how price wars start.

"Feels right" pricing is guesswork in a suit. It reflects your willingness to pay, not your customer's — and you can't improve a number you never measured.

📌Example · One big logo, one tiny price

Picture a small analytics startup that lands one of the largest companies in the US. They are so excited by the name that they charge a fixed $10,000 a year.

For the client, that's a rounding error; the insights help steer decisions worth millions. For the startup, it becomes a trap: the client asks for custom reports, the team turns into an in-house agency, and there's no room to raise the price without "renegotiating with a giant". They priced the prestige of the logo, not the value they delivered.

From guessing to Willingness to Pay

From guessing to Willingness to Pay

The way out is to change the question. Instead of "what should we charge?", ask: what is this worth to the customer?

That's where Willingness to Pay (WTP) comes in. WTP is the maximum amount a customer would pay for your product before they'd rather choose an alternative or go without it. It isn't set by your costs or your competitors. It's set by the value you create — the time saved, the money earned, the risk avoided — compared with the customer's next best option.

Value-based pricing builds on WTP in four steps:

  • Understand the problem you solve and who has it most.

  • Quantify the impact: hours, dollars, mistakes avoided.

  • Research what customers would pay for that outcome.

  • Charge a share of the value you create — enough to be worth it for you, small enough that the customer clearly wins.

Your costs still matter: they set the floor below which you lose money. But the customer's value sets the ceiling. Most bad pricing comes from staring at the floor and never looking up. In the next lesson you'll put real numbers on value; in lesson 3 you'll learn to ask customers about it without awkwardness.

Why smart founders underprice

Why smart founders underprice

If value-based pricing is so obviously better, why does almost everyone underprice? Mostly because of loss aversion — the tendency to feel a loss more strongly than an equal gain.

In pricing, it shows up as fear of losing a sale you don't even have yet. A "no" at a higher price feels like losing something, so you quietly lower the price to avoid that feeling. The result is a familiar list of habits:

  • starting low "to get traction" and never moving;

  • avoiding any test of a higher price;

  • accepting bad deals "just to get the revenue";

  • never raising prices for existing customers.

Each one feels safe. Together they mean you never learn what you're leaving on the table.

⚠️Common mistake · Treating price as permanent

Founders often think a price, once published, is carved in stone, so they make it low enough to never be rejected. In reality, price is something you test and adjust like any other part of the product. Set a price you can defend with evidence, then plan to revisit it — the later lessons on testing and raising prices show how to do that safely.

Let price grow with your customer

Let price grow with your customer

Even a well-chosen number can be attached to the wrong unit. A value metric is the unit you charge for — per user, per transaction, per hour of usage. A good value metric makes your revenue grow when your customers' success grows.

| Company | Charges per | Grows when the customer… | | --- | --- | --- | | Slack | Active user | Has more people using it | | Stripe | Transaction | Sells more | | AWS | Compute usage | Runs more workloads |

Slack's per-active-user pricing is a good example: a team pays more only when more people actually use it, which is exactly when Slack is creating more value. Stripe earns more only when its customers sell more.

Bad value metrics do the opposite. Charging per seat when only one admin logs in forces customers to share passwords. A flat fee for wildly different usage overcharges small customers and undercharges large ones. Charging per feature when features only make sense together creates confusion instead of value.

💡Tip

Ask: "When my customer gets more value, what number goes up?" Projects, clients, users, revenue, messages sent. That number is your best candidate for a value metric.

For Taskbook, it's a natural question: does an agency get more value from more users (more people coordinated) or more projects (more client work running)? Their current plans use both — free is limited by projects, Pro is priced per user. Keep that in mind; it comes back when we design tiers.

Practice: audit your current price

Practice: audit your current price

✅Do it now

Spend 30 minutes on an honest pricing audit of your product (or one you know well):

  • Write down how your current price was chosen — be honest about whether it was cost-plus, competitor-based or "felt right".

  • Describe the main outcome a customer gets, and put a rough number on it (hours or dollars per month).

  • Name the customer's next best alternative and what it costs them.

  • Write a first guess of their Willingness to Pay — a range is fine.

  • Name your current value metric and the metric that would grow with customer success.

Use the template below and keep it — you'll refine every line in the next two lessons.

📋Template · One-page pricing audit

Copy

Product: [name] Current price: [$ per unit] How we chose it: [cost-plus / competitor / felt right / other]

Main outcome for the customer: [what changes for them] Rough value per month: [$ or hours] Next best alternative: [tool, hire, spreadsheet, doing nothing] — costs [$] First guess at WTP: [$ range]

Current value metric: [per user / per project / flat fee] Metric that grows with customer success: [your idea] One thing I'm afraid of if I charge more: [write it down]

Practical assignment

Complete a one-page pricing audit

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. Why Most People Price Wrong
  2. Value-Based vs Cost-Based Pricing
  3. Talking to Customers About Price
  4. Free Trials: Fundamentals That Work
  5. Reverse Trials: The Premium-First Approach
  6. Freemium vs Free Trial vs Reverse Trial
  7. Price Testing: Methods and Pitfalls
  8. Tiering and Packaging
  9. Selling Annual Plans
  10. Price Psychology: Anchoring, Decoy, and Charm Pricing
  11. When and How to Raise Prices
  12. Your Pricing Launch Checklist