How Many Uses Does a Brick Have?
How Many Uses Does a Brick Have? — Creative Thinking: Come Up With Better Ideas on Demand. “I’m just not a creative person”; What the brick exercise actually tests; Why later ideas can be different; Fictional worked example: fewer ideas, more interesting options; Where this experiment leads. Practical assignment: The 10-minute brick.
Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.
Topics covered
- “I’m just not a creative person”
- What the brick exercise actually tests
- Why later ideas can be different
- Fictional worked example: fewer ideas, more interesting options
- Where this experiment leads
“I’m just not a creative person”
When a request to come up with something useful produces a blank mind, it is easy to blame an inborn lack of creativity. There is a simpler possibility: the first two or three ideas seem weak, so the search stops. Yet the first responses often reproduce what is already familiar. This lesson tests a different behavior: keep writing without evaluating each idea, then examine when the least obvious options appeared.
Fictional example. Liam, a 32-year-old logistics coordinator for a chain of 14 bakeries, likes spreadsheets and calls himself uncreative. In this educational scenario, about 11% of the products baked each Sunday remain unsold—roughly $1,900 per week. When his manager asks for a solution by the end of the month, Liam opens a spreadsheet and writes nothing. That does not yet demonstrate an absence of ability: he has not started a process for generating options.
What the brick exercise actually tests
In an Alternative Uses Task, a person has limited time to name as many unusual uses as possible for an ordinary object such as a brick, paperclip, or shoe. It exercises divergent thinking: producing multiple possible answers when there is no single correct one. It does not measure all of creativity, establish how creative someone is in general, or predict the success of a real project.
Research on the “creative cliff illusion” identified an important forecasting error. Across eight studies, participants often expected continued work to yield progressively worse ideas, although the creativity of later ideas frequently remained stable or improved. Productivity—the number of ideas produced per minute—can decline without an automatic decline in quality. A slowdown is therefore information about pace, not an instruction to stop.
Why later ideas can be different
Ask for uses of a brick and nearby associations arrive quickly: build a wall, hold a door, add weight. After those, the search slows because it must move to another category: a brick in a kitchen, a game, music, or printing. In divergent-thinking research, later responses have often received higher originality ratings, a pattern called the serial order effect. However, a newer methodological analysis describes the average effect as small and sensitive to scoring choices. A later idea is therefore not guaranteed to be better.
A common mistake is judging every entry immediately. An obvious idea then gets deleted before it can lead to a new category. During generation, record repetitions and variations too; evaluation begins after the timer. If stuck, combine the object with another object or role—a practical prompt discussed by Reddit contributors—but mark that a prompt was used so the time segments can still be compared honestly.
Fictional worked example: fewer ideas, more interesting options
In the fictional example, Liam sets a 10-minute timer and draws a line every 2 minutes. He records 23 uses: 9, 5, 4, 3, and 2 across the five consecutive segments. The sum is 23. His flow clearly slowed, but the count alone says nothing about quality.
After time expires, Liam selects the three ideas he finds most unexpected. A stamp for pressing a pattern into bread crust appeared around minute 5. In the final segment, he listed a brick as a heat store for a bread basket and as an object a baker might tap to keep a kneading rhythm. The heat-store idea is an imaginative example, not advice to heat a brick: an unknown material may be unsuitable for food contact or cause a burn. The educational conclusion is narrower. Two of his three selections appeared in his slowest segment, so stopping at minute 4 would have changed this particular attempt’s outcome.
Where this experiment leads
The brick offers a neutral way to observe your process before working on a problem that matters. In lessons 1–3, you will observe how options emerge, choose a project, and refine its question. In lessons 4–11, you will apply eight idea-generation methods. In lessons 12–14, you will use AI as an assistant, compare options, and plan a cheap test. In lessons 15–16, you will build a habit and assemble a personal protocol.
That is a route, not a guarantee of a brilliant or successful idea. Writing serves a practical purpose: it makes options countable, preserves when they appeared, and lets you revisit discarded combinations. In the final lesson, you can repeat the exercise under the same 10-minute conditions. Compare the number and distribution of your own responses, but do not turn one home exercise into a scientific assessment of your creativity.
Practical assignment
The 10-minute brick
Continue to learningCourse outline
- How Many Uses Does a Brick Have?
- What Counts as a Creative Idea — and Your Course Project
- Are You Solving the Right Problem?
- Quantity First: Deferred Judgment and the Idea Quota
- Constraints as a Springboard
- Who Has Solved This Before? Thinking by Analogy
- SCAMPER: Seven Questions for Anything
- Random Stimulus: Connecting the Unconnected
- Break Your Assumptions
- Step Away to Come Back: Incubation, Walking and Sleep
- Coming Up With Ideas Together — the Right Way
- AI as an Idea Partner
- Choosing Your Best Idea
- Test It in 48 Hours for $0
- The Idea Habit and Your Store of Experiences
- My Creative Protocol