Free lesson

Are You Solving the Right Problem?

Are You Solving the Right Problem? — Creative Thinking: Come Up With Better Ideas on Demand. The question sets the field of answers; Six reframing moves; Fictional worked example: from leftovers to forecasting; How to choose a working question. Practical assignment: Ten reframes for your project card.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • The question sets the field of answers
  • Six reframing moves
  • Fictional worked example: from leftovers to forecasting
  • How to choose a working question

The question sets the field of answers

The first statement of a problem often describes a visible symptom rather than the outcome people need. The slow-elevator story exists in several versions, so treat it as a teaching illustration, not a documented case. Ask “How can we speed up the elevators?” and the answers concern motors, control algorithms, or another shaft. Ask “How can we make the wait less burdensome?” and a different set appears: a clear time estimate, useful information, or a more pleasant waiting area.

A new frame does not prove that the first one was wrong. Slow service may still be a genuine technical problem. The point is to examine several plausible accounts of the situation before committing resources to one solution. For example, “How might we get more people into the weekly meeting?” assumes that the meeting is necessary. “How might we ensure people receive and use the required information?” permits a short written update, an asynchronous discussion, or a meeting reserved for unresolved matters.

A 1971 study offers limited but relevant evidence about problem formulation. Researchers observed 31 male advanced art students as they selected objects, composed a still life, and drew it. More discovery-oriented activity while forming the problem was associated with higher originality ratings. This was a correlation in one artistic task, not proof that spending longer on a problem always improves every kind of solution.

Six reframing moves

Take the “How might we…?” question from the previous lesson and deliberately turn it six ways.

| Move | Question | |---|---| | Wider | What larger goal is this problem part of? | | Narrower | What specific part, time, or situation should we isolate? | | Why? ×3 | Why does this matter? Why does that answer matter? Why does that matter? | | Whose problem? | Who experiences the consequence, and how would that person describe it? | | Flip it | What is the opposite problem or desired reverse state? | | What if it were easy? | What could we do in five minutes or with what is already available? |

“Why? ×3” can move attention from a symptom toward a need, but it does not automatically uncover one true root cause. Each answer is a hypothesis to check. “Whose problem?” exposes different criteria: Sunday bakery leftovers may be a cost to finance, extra work for shop staff, and a lack of fresh choice for customers. “What if it were easy?” temporarily removes the assumption that the costliest or hardest version deserves attention first. A real reframe changes the kind of answers available; replacing “decrease” with “reduce” does not.

Fictional worked example: from leftovers to forecasting

In this fictional teaching example, Liam starts with “How might we stop throwing away baked goods on Sundays?” He produces ten versions: 1) make Sunday more profitable; 2) get value from everything baked; 3) sell the last 30 items left at 4 p.m.; 4) bake as much as customers will buy; 5) make the evening write-off easier for staff; 6) give customers fresh bread late on Sunday; 7) run out of bread deliberately; 8) make leftovers desirable; 9) cut waste using only data already collected; 10) try a change in one shop next Sunday.

Version 4 came from a chain: “Why are there leftovers?” — too much is baked. “Why?” — future demand is unknown. “Why?” — Sunday demand varies. The revised question becomes: “How might we match Sunday baking more closely to actual demand?” It opens a different class of ideas: smaller batches, the timing of additional baking, pre-orders, or sales-history use. The chain proves nothing yet. Before changing production, Liam must inspect the data and ask whether leftovers might instead arise from a minimum batch size or assortment requirements.

How to choose a working question

After ten reframes, test each against three criteria. First, does it admit several meaningfully different answers? A question with one answer built in, such as “How might we introduce a discount?”, disguises a solution as a problem. Second, can you influence it within the project? “How might we change every customer’s culture?” is too broad for one shop to test. Third, does it still match the signs of a good solution established in the previous lesson?

For every new version, name one idea that fits it but did not arise from the original question. If you cannot, you have probably changed the wording rather than the frame. Select one working question and explain the choice in one sentence. Keep the others as reserve angles. If “why?” produces no useful answer, ask, “What specifically would change if this problem were solved?” Then ask the same of the answer. Do not label the selection the finally “right” question: it is the most useful testable frame supported by the information currently available.

Practical assignment

Ten reframes for your project card

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. How Many Uses Does a Brick Have?
  2. What Counts as a Creative Idea — and Your Course Project
  3. Are You Solving the Right Problem?
  4. Quantity First: Deferred Judgment and the Idea Quota
  5. Constraints as a Springboard
  6. Who Has Solved This Before? Thinking by Analogy
  7. SCAMPER: Seven Questions for Anything
  8. Random Stimulus: Connecting the Unconnected
  9. Break Your Assumptions
  10. Step Away to Come Back: Incubation, Walking and Sleep
  11. Coming Up With Ideas Together — the Right Way
  12. AI as an Idea Partner
  13. Choosing Your Best Idea
  14. Test It in 48 Hours for $0
  15. The Idea Habit and Your Store of Experiences
  16. My Creative Protocol