Free lesson

What Counts as a Creative Idea — and Your Course Project

What Counts as a Creative Idea — and Your Course Project — Creative Thinking: Come Up With Better Ideas on Demand. New and appropriate; Everyday creativity counts; Choose your course project; The “How might we…?” question; Success signs and the project card. Practical assignment: Create your project card.

Demo edition. The materials are undergoing editorial review.

Topics covered

  • New and appropriate
  • Everyday creativity counts
  • Choose your course project
  • The “How might we…?” question
  • Success signs and the project card

New and appropriate

A creative idea needs two qualities: originality and effectiveness. In plain language, it must be new in the relevant context and useful for the stated purpose. An unusual thought that does not address the problem is not yet a creative solution. A familiar action may be useful while changing very little.

In the fictional case of Liam’s bakery, “send yesterday’s bread to pigeons by drone” is unusual but does not reduce the loss sensibly. “Bake less every Sunday” is more practical, but it could leave empty shelves. A preorder arrangement that the chain has not tried could be creative if it actually cuts leftovers without losing sales.

“New” need not mean first in human history: an idea is judged relative to particular people, places, times, and constraints. Effectiveness also depends on whose purpose counts. While generating ideas, do not reject strange options too early; use the criteria later when selecting.

Everyday creativity counts

Creativity is not limited to work that changes an entire field. The Four C model distinguishes a personal insight during learning (mini-c), everyday creativity (little-c), professional expertise (Pro-c), and an eminent contribution recognized over time (Big-C). This course mainly concerns the first two: simplifying a process at work, organizing a cramped hallway, or reaching a personally new understanding of a difficult subject.

These levels are a research model, not a ranking of human worth. They help you avoid comparing an everyday problem with an eminent inventor’s career. A 2004 review of 70 studies found that well-designed creativity training can improve measured performance, particularly when it teaches thinking skills through realistic exercises. That does not guarantee an equal effect for every learner. Nor is there evidence for sorting whole people into “left-brained” and “right-brained” types: a functional-connectivity study did not find that general pattern of hemispheric dominance.

Choose your course project

The following lessons will apply each technique to one problem of your own. A suitable project passes four tests: the problem is real; you can influence it or run a small test; you do not already have the answer; and a test is possible within one week. “Choose between two apps I have already researched” is mainly a decision among options, not a search for a new one. “Fix my career” is too broad.

In a fictional example, Liam considers Sunday bakery leftovers, shoes in his narrow hallway, and his football team’s scheduling problem. He chooses the leftovers because he can test a change in one or two shops on a single Sunday. His first phrase, “Reduce Sunday leftovers,” does not yet open a useful search space. A working problem should matter, but it should also be small enough that later ideas can be tested through action rather than merely discussed.

The “How might we…?” question

Turn the problem statement into an open question: “How might we…?” It directs attention toward possibilities without promising that every answer will work. “Sunday leftovers are too high” is a statement. “How might we reduce the baked goods we throw away on Sundays?” invites several answers.

The question’s width matters. “How might we end all food waste?” is too broad for a one-week test. “How might we sell leftover croissants at half price?” already contains a specific solution and closes off other routes. Practical Reddit discussions likewise distinguish questions that ask you to choose among known options from questions that require designing something new; that is a useful working distinction, not a universal scientific law. The next lesson will show how to adjust the frame’s width.

Success signs and the project card

Write two or three signs by which you could later recognize a suitable solution. They should represent the purpose and important boundaries: outcome, cost, time, workload, or number of people involved. Include at least one number when possible. Do not use these signs to eliminate ideas during generation: they set direction now, while comparison comes after you have created options.

Liam’s fictional card says, “How might we stop throwing away baked goods on Sundays?” A good solution keeps waste below 6% of what is baked, costs no more than $300 a month, and adds no work for sales staff. Those figures are fictional teaching conditions, not industry benchmarks. A complete card contains a short problem description, one “How might we…?” question, and 2–3 testable signs. If a criterion cannot be observed, specify what data would show whether it has been met.

Practical assignment

Create your project card

Continue to learning

Course outline

  1. How Many Uses Does a Brick Have?
  2. What Counts as a Creative Idea — and Your Course Project
  3. Are You Solving the Right Problem?
  4. Quantity First: Deferred Judgment and the Idea Quota
  5. Constraints as a Springboard
  6. Who Has Solved This Before? Thinking by Analogy
  7. SCAMPER: Seven Questions for Anything
  8. Random Stimulus: Connecting the Unconnected
  9. Break Your Assumptions
  10. Step Away to Come Back: Incubation, Walking and Sleep
  11. Coming Up With Ideas Together — the Right Way
  12. AI as an Idea Partner
  13. Choosing Your Best Idea
  14. Test It in 48 Hours for $0
  15. The Idea Habit and Your Store of Experiences
  16. My Creative Protocol